<HTML>Jason, Renny is right about which one, is a preference.
We use strictly air driven buffers/polishers for 99% of our Big Truck work. I revert back to the air driven "RO" to put the product on, then remove it with the "D" handle Makita, on cars and suv's and small trucks. I like the soft start of the makita and varable speed controls close to the thumb where you can speed it up without stopping, and looking down each time. My preference here only!
I wuz strictly a Milwaukee / Porter Cable man before using the MAkita at a friend of mines Body Shop. Using Dewalt,Porter Cable and the Milwaukee machines all day I switched over to the Makita.
I tried a Cyclo Buffer the other day,and worked on a big section on an Aluminum Tanker Trailer. I personally didn't like the machine much. Much heavier than the air driven drum buffers, and flapper wheel pencil buffers,and not nearly as effective!
Now this is not comparing Red Delicious Apples vs Red Delicious Apples, but I'm going to keep it around until I get one of my Big Truck Customers
personal vehicles to Detail,then give it a good go!
Joe,Ketch,Brian,Bud and others will have a different tune to this Thread,but starting out ---- Get a Porter-Cable "RA" to use to work the material on with ,then Get a Makita Varible Speed "D" handle to use in Correcting and Polishing.... Remember opinions are like "Ass-holes", everybodys got one.
One other thing! Do you know someone in the Body Shop business or Auto/Truck Salvage Business? Most folks will let you practice on old fenders and other body panels. The up side to being at a good Body Shop location is that you can get some free pointers, of do's and don't's while there practicing on the old panels........ Brandy !</HTML>